Cognition: An Erica Reed Thriller - Episode 1: The Hangman review

The Good:

Detailed and gorgeous artwork; outstanding soundtrack; gripping third act and solid ending sequence; reasonably strong voice acting.

The Bad:

Supporting characters are generally thin and not likable; setup for puzzles sometimes stretches credibility.

Our Verdict:

Though flawed, the first episode of Cognition leaves a great final impression and sets up a series that could become a major achievement for episodic adventure gaming.

There's something special in the air anytime a new indie studio releases their first commercial project, but there's a particular significance to the launch of the first episode of Cognition: An Erica Reed Thriller from Phoenix Online Studios. Not only does it come from the same team that spent the better part of a decade seeing its unofficial fan-made King's Quest 9 sequel through all sorts of potential death screens to the light of day as The Silver Lining, a flawed but joyously ambitious episodic freeware epic, but adventure game luminary Jane Jensen has been brought on board as a hands-on story consultant for Cognition. Not surprisingly, Episode 1: The Hangman packs a dark storytelling wallop within an impressive, if sometimes very uneven, game. 

The game's prologue sets up the background story of Erica Reed, the titular heroine of the FBI's Boston office. The lengthy opening sequence takes you through the events of a horrible family tragedy that sets the stage for Erica's thirst for bringing criminals to justice. The tonal change from the family-friendly fare of The Silver Lining could not be more extreme, as the prologue is gory, profane, depressing, and framed with the most unsettling quasi-industrial soundtrack I can remember. Moving to the present day, there is little more joy to be found as the game takes you right into the scene of a brutal midnight hanging, complete with blood splattered on the walls due to a particularly violent finishing touch by the killer.

Having properly expressed its adult nature, Cognition then settles into more of a traditional detective story, with some nice emotional touches as Erica continues to confront the after-effects of her brother's senseless death and now fights to control the special cognitive powers that are beginning to drive her mad. It is within the supernatural nature of these cognitive powers that Jane Jensen's influence is clearly felt. Erica, with the help of an antique shop curator named Rose (a matronly rendition of Dr. John from Sins of the Fathers), develops new psychic abilities and uses them to re-open an old case and track down a vicious murderer.

The first episode of Cognition is, understandably, primarily about setup—Erica's initial power (the ability to see the past actions associated with a significant object) must be explained, and then two more powers (projection and regression) must be introduced and brought into focus. The episode also requires the introduction of multiple characters, very few of which are more than one-dimensional at this point, and a quick primer on the horrific background of the murders that form the game’s background story, plus other related crimes. It is remarkable that the episode compresses as much story as it does into 5-6 hours of playtime, but don't expect a lot of resolution, as the episode ends with a bleak and explosive cliffhanger and plenty of story threads unwound.

The game is at its best when making use of the cognitive powers, a creative spin on an otherwise very traditional point-and-click adventure game. The interface is a standard context-sensitive pop-up type, with only the addition of the Cognition sphere at the bottom left. These powers are used in sometimes brilliant ways, but are not relied on as a constant crutch for solving all puzzles. The first power is straightforward, used almost like an inventory item in order to see a flashback cutscene. The projection power, when available, involves selecting three related hotspots in order to project evidence that previously existed in the location. It’s a nifty way to bring back a corpse (or other less grotesque evidence) that you no longer have access to. The regression power is best left unspoiled, but provides the game’s best and most complex puzzle as you assist a witness in reconstructing their own jumbled memories of a significant event. 

The game is definitely not at its best when the pace slows down, and that is mostly the fault of inconsistent writing and implausible actions. Cognition can be riveting in its most intense moments, but nearly preposterous when Erica's normal workaday interactions with the other characters are the focus. Your partner John is a lazy slob who never gets up from his desk to help you and really likes doughnuts; your boss Davies is a brash and bullying authoritarian who really likes to give orders; the forensic lab guy Terence is a shabbily-dressed, glasses-wearing geek who really likes gadgets; and Gwen, the receptionist and evidence clerk is blonde eye candy who presents all the professionalism (and age) of a Friday Night Lights cheerleader. Not exactly the most nuanced supporting cast in the world, and generally an unpleasant group of thinly-written characters.

They're a well-drawn bunch, though; the art in Cognition is brilliant. The cel-shaded characters are gorgeously animated over equally striking painted 2D backgrounds. It is easy to imagine this is what the natural progression of Sierra's own classic adventures would have looked like after 20 years. There are some visual quirks in the character design—it's hard to look past the frozen cake-frosting that appears to have been used for female hair—but the art oozes dark style and boasts a number of very impressive cutscenes that unleash the insanity in Erica's mind at pivotal gaming moments, to great emotional effect that surely must make Jane Jensen proud. Dark locations such as the cemetery and crime scenes feature excellent moody lighting, and other areas like the antique shop and a suspect’s apartment contain painstakingly vivid background details. The game has over 20 backgrounds in total, which are uniformly impressive.

The music, an original score by Austin Haynes (whose soundtrack to The Silver Lining was an extremely impressive and varied opus that this writer often uses as background reading music), is fantastic, providing raw and unsettling darkness and quiet moodiness, hitting all the right notes at the right time. The voice acting also consists of mostly strong, capable actors making the best of the script they were given. The crucial choice of Erica's voice was well-cast as Raleigh Holmes, daughter of Jensen's husband Robert Holmes and herself an accomplished and recognized voice and musical talent. She shows impressive emotional range and manages to make even some silly dialogue carry great heft at crucial times. If this is the standard set by their commercial debut, Phoenix Online has put together a technical team that promises great things to come.

While its menacing violence may be on the strong side, Cognition is a game well-suited for those with limited adventure experience. There are little features like the ability to highlight all inventory items that are allowed to be combined and a pop-up menu icon that indicates when an object can be used with inventory that save a great deal of excess clicking present in many adventures. The game also includes an excellent hint system (in the well-designed form of a text message conversation with your father) that will render any external walkthrough useless. There are no real action sequences, and only one scene that can lead to death, which can be rather quickly undone.

Don't expect a game made by Sierra devotees to avoid an opportunity to drive you puzzle-mad, though. The game is bloated with instances where puzzles are artificially inserted into important moments just to make sure you feel like you're solving something. Of particular annoyance is a mid-game interrogation sequence of a hungry homeless man with crucial information about a murderer; the hunt to locate and acquire the correct food for his apparently very restrictive palate feels like its own 'Quest' game. Also somewhat laughable is a puzzle that involves breaking into your boss's office in plain sight of the entire floor of detectives as though no one would notice. Hearing the main character narrate her own actions with a sigh and "There goes your badge, Erica" doesn't make the entire situation any less absurd. These types of puzzles are not very difficult (almost no puzzle in the game is) but they too often strain the bounds of real-world credibility, which is acceptable in the Land of the Green Isles, less so in the midst of a Boston murder investigation.

With its occasional descent into one-dimensional caricatures for supporting characters, immature dialogue, and implausible puzzles, the first episode of Cognition doesn't quite fulfill the series' aspirations of greatness just yet. But even with these early reservations, I really enjoyed almost everything about The Hangman. It is soaked with gloomy style, is gorgeous to look at and listen to, sets up its plot points with great precision, and takes off in the third act as it builds to a huge climax with a disquieting final shot that makes me genuinely eager to play the second episode. That's about the highest compliment you can pay to the first in an episodic series.

The ambition of César Bittar must also be praised; he is credited as not only Phoenix Online's CEO, but sole designer, writer, director, and producer of this episode—perhaps to the game's detriment if the sometimes uneven script was not externally edited. Bittar has already stated that other designers will helm, or co-helm, future episodes, and the influence of a larger pool of talent will hopefully further improve on this highly promising beginning. With some storytelling and dialogue enhancements added to the already impressive technical achievements, there is no limit to what Phoenix Online may be able to accomplish in future episodes.

AD Cognition: An Erica Reed Thriller - Episode 1: The Hangman can be purchased at:
Adventure Gamers StoreGOG   • Apple App Store  

Game Info
Digital October 30 2012 Phoenix Online Studios

Where To Buy

Cognition: Game of the Year Edition (Season Pass Bundle)

DRM-Free at Adventure Gamers Store


Or get it from: GOG   Apple App Store  

Affiliate Links

User Score

Average based on 26 ratings

Log in or Register to post ratings.

User Reviews

Posted by Antrax on Jan 29, 2015

Ridiculously constrictive

The Hangman is a decent game. It's well-written, it's technically adequate and the puzzles, while easy, aren't insulting. However, it's... Read the review »

Posted by Niclas on Nov 2, 2012
The first 2 hours of gameplay was just awesome. So much energy and awesomeness. If the game would have stayed like that the whole time, I... Read the review »

Showing 3 of 30

About the Author
Stinger's avatar
Evan Dickens
Staff Writer
Evan Dickens is the former editor-in-chief of Adventure Gamers. Now semi-retired, he meanders about on his front porch firing his slingshot at passing cars and griping about "the old days". Full Bio


Zin Zin
Nov 1, 2012

Ok, now I REALLY want to play this! Thank you for this well-written and detailed review; it covered pretty much all the questions I had about the game.

Nov 1, 2012

i plan on getting this when theres more purchase options!!

dekaneas297 dekaneas297
Nov 2, 2012

Didn’t like the whole cognitive powers aspect. If it was more automatic (triggers when it approaches certain objects/places) it would be better. The continuous “press the cognition power element button to see if…” frustrated me. And Erica is too agry and rough. No female aspect in her. Nice graphics though.

Nov 2, 2012

dekaneas297, I think that Erica is acting like this because she is frustrated with all the issue of her brother Scott. You can understand her situation…
She also has to be very rough because of her job - capturing very cruel murderers and seeing dead bodies, blood and etc’...
I don’t know how she can handle all this, I admire her Smile

Asentra Asentra
Nov 3, 2012

A decent game. Extremely short (even for an episode), very few puzzles, the pace of the game is inconsistent. The lead character is very likeable, but like the article said - the rest - not so much. The cognitive powers were a great idea, although there’s a huge Blackwell influence. The plot as a whole is good and the ambience of the game is truly a thriller one - that’s Cognition’s strongest point.

Sefir Sefir
Nov 5, 2012

Just finished the game. I liked the difficulty and the fact that it was pretty long for just an episode. I liked the artistic comic style and the voices, found the characters very likeable and realistic. What I didn’t like was the interface for the cognition powers. While it is a good idea, the whole “are you sure?” clicking really annoyed me.  Also, I found the music very monotonous at some points. Generally, a very good and enjoyable game. I expect the same quality with the rest of the series.

Interplay Interplay
Nov 5, 2012

I thought this was a great game and a great start to the series.  I disagree with Asentra on the length.  I thought the game was very long for an adventure game episode (much longer than comparable Telltale episodes).

Buyer please beware that there are several bugs that make the game totally unwinnable without going back to an earlier save (see my forum post for details).  One might want to wait until it gets (hopefully) patched.  If you want to experience the game now, I would just say save early and save often so you don’t get hosed.

Can’t wait for the second ep.

tomimt tomimt
Mar 22, 2013

Just played this through and I have to say, that I don’t agree with the art comments of the review. I just can’t in all honesty say that the character art was very well done or animated. All in all the 3D art was rather ugly. Some of the 2D backgrounds looked a bit rushed as well, but on a whole those did work much better than the 3D art. Also the UI could have used some more polish.

Also check out...

A Short Tale review

PC Mac iPhone iPad Android

Kathy Rain review

PC Mac