Aggie Awards

2009 Aggie Awards

Best Adventure of 2009: Tales of Monkey Island



With five individual Aggies to its credit already (one for every episode?), the grand winner for 2009 should come as no surprise. Not so long ago, however, it wasn’t so certain. The stunning announcement of Tales of Monkey Island was met with great enthusiasm, but also trepidation. After nearly a decade of silence, could a brand new installment possibly meet the expectations of passionate fans of the Golden Era classics? When more was revealed, the concerns grew for some: “It’s 3D! It’s episodic! It’s not point-and-click! It’s not LucasArts!” But whatever it may or may not be, from July to December the five serial Tales convinced us all of one simple thing:

Tales of Monkey Island is good. It’s very, very good. And today it’s the owner of our Best Adventure of 2009 Aggie Award.

Despite some noteworthy competition that could very well have won in any other year, Tales stood out from the rest for its achievements in every relevant area. With an epic storyline that blew away the standards of previous episodic series, a wide variety of creative scenarios, laugh-out-loud dialogue, and all the usual production qualities we’ve come to expect of Telltale, Tales consistently showed that the modern day franchise is in the right hands. With its 5-star apex in Lair of the Leviathan, there were inevitable ups and downs (both literally and figuratively), but there was never a dull moment, and no game more deserving of the top award we have to bestow.

Runners-Up: Machinarium, Emerald City Confidential, Professor Layton and the Diabolical Box


Readers’ Choice: Tales of Monkey Island



Even before this, 2009 probably would have been known as the Year of the Monkey for adventure gamers. This time last year, Monkey Island seemed dead, but the surprise five-episode Tales rekindled our love for Guybrush Throwback and the gang, and is a deserving winner of the readers’ choice Game of the Year Aggie. Full props to the runners-up, too, as two indies rounding out the top three is a wonderful accomplishment for the small teams behind them.

Runners-Up: Machinarium, Time Gentlemen, Please!


And so ends the 2009 Aggie Awards. Still to come, a few administrative notes and a complete 2009 game list, but don’t forget to leave your feedback on all the choices we got right. Or wrong. But mostly right.

Continued on the next page...

Tales of Monkey Island can be purchased at:

Affiliate Links

Related Games

Tales of Monkey Island

Platform(s): iPad, iPhone/iPod Touch, PC, Wii

The Blackwell Convergence

Platform(s): iPad, iPhone/iPod Touch, Mac, PC

Silent Hill: Shattered Memories

Platform(s): PlayStation 2, PSP, Wii


Platform(s): Android, iPad, iPhone, Mac, PC, PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4, Vita, Wii, Linux

Dark Fall: Lost Souls

Platform(s): PC

The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition

Platform(s): iPad, PC, Xbox 360

Re-release of the 1990 classic with new HD graphics, full voiceovers, and director's commentary.

Mystery Case Files: Dire Grove

Platform(s): iPad, PC

Professor Layton and the Diabolical Box

Platform(s): DS

Also known as Professor Layton and Pandora's Box

About the Author
Other articles...