Al Emmo and the Lost Dutchman’s Mine review

The Good: Inventive puzzles, great characters, loads of interaction, and an engaging story.
The Bad: Horrible character animation and opening cinematics, plus an annoying main character voice drag down what could have been a great game.
Our Verdict: A charming old school comic adventure that's definitely worth a play through if you can get past the graphic weaknesses and the main character's voice.

It's a scenario we've all seen a hundred times in movies and on television. One of the characters has finally managed to land a date with a beautiful girl, but only if he can also find a date for her not-so attractive friend. So he hits up his buddy to go out with her, and when asked what she looks like, he responds that she has a good personality. That may sound like a rather random introduction to an adventure game review, but when my girlfriend asked me last week how I was enjoying Al Emmo and the Lost Dutchman's Mine, the first thing that popped out of my mouth was that it has a great personality.

Al Emmo is the first retail game from Himalaya Studios, the independent developer whose founding members were responsible for wowing us all with their remakes of the first two King's Quest games. And while it is evident that the same love that went into those games also went into Al Emmo, somewhere along the line they seem to have taken a misstep that keeps the game from being the great original debut that it could have been.

The story begins with an introductory scene in which two men and their team have finally come to the end of their quest to find a lost mine filled with Aztec gold. From there we move to the present, as our main character Al Emmo arrives by train in the small town of Anozira to meet his mail order bride. Al is your stereotypical nebbish character, with his comb-over hairdo, ill-fitting clothes, bad posture, and annoying voice. And, because this is an adventure game, once Al arrives in town, everything begins to go wrong almost immediately. Left without a bride, Al soon falls for a bar singer named Rita, and over the course of the nine act story, must fight for her love against a swarthy lothario by the name of Antonio Bandana, and discover the secret of The Dutchman's Mine and its treasures.

My first thought when the story started coming together was that it could easily be the plot for "Leisure Suit Larry 9: Wild West Larry", and combined with the nerdy character of Al Emmo, the comparisons get even closer. But while it treads some of the same ground as that classic Sierra series, Himalaya does manage to distance itself from those games by creating a town filled with pop culture references and a memorable cast of characters, from a missile-wielding gopher to a cola-addicted Indian chief, and an exterminator ready to take his war against termites to the extreme, just to name a few.

In any comedy adventure game, the impact of its humor is going to be subjective. I personally found Al Emmo's story to be funny, and there were a few laugh-out-loud moments to be had. Himalaya went with the "throw a bunch of jokes out and see what sticks" concept, and of course not everything worked, but I thought they did a good job of toeing the line between amusing jokes and groaners.

It's a shame, then, that some people won't make it far enough into the story to see how good it is, having been immediately turned off by the game's graphics. When I saw the Himalaya logo come up on the screen -- also evocative of the Sierra logo, but frankly much cooler looking -- I was ready to be amazed. And when the introductory 3D cutscene started and the first characters came on the screen, I was heartbroken. The design of the characters was incredibly generic, their rendering was awful, and the characters moved like they were stuck in molasses. As the scene shifted to modern day, once again I was dumbstruck by the amateur quality of the presentation. At that point, had I not been reviewing the game, it would have been relegated to my stack of "I'll play those later" games. Fortunately, it turns out that only the introduction and first act cinematics are done in this style. The rest of the game's cutscenes are done as a series of comic panels, each looking very much like Italian comic art, and I was blown away by how good they were and how much they pulled me further into the story. I only wish the introductions had been redone in this format, as it wouldn't have been so jarring to switch styles, and certainly would have made a much better first impression.

Once the gameplay actually starts, things begin to look a little better. For starters, the background graphics are full of gorgeous handpainted screens, and even when traveling through a desert area, the screens all manage to have a unique look to them, filled with little touches that you may not notice immediately but will catch over time as you travel through them again. Regrettably, the game is presented in 640x400 resolution, which lessens the effectiveness of the visuals considerably. The portrait graphics used when conversing with characters are not great, but well done, and add a nice touch. However, the characters themselves are rendered in 3D, and fare just as badly as their cutscene counterparts. Minor characters in most cases don't seem to have any form to them, with arms and legs made up of simple tubes with a head and boots. And while the major characters are a little better, they don't blend in well with the background graphics, and they move like they're underwater. Since you'll be seeing a lot of Al running from screen to screen, this gets old fast.

Continued on the next page...

What's your verdict?

Want to share your own thoughts about this game? Share your personal score, or better yet, leave your own review!

Scoring System - Editorial Policies

Game Info

Al Emmo and the Lost Dutchman’s Mine

Platform:
PC

Genre:
Comedy, Mystery

Developer:
Himalaya Studios


Game Page »

Worldwide September 5 2006 Himalaya Studios


User Score

Average based on 3 ratings

Log in or Register to post ratings.

User Reviews
No user reviews yet. Why not post one!



Screenshots
Showing 3 of 12

About the Author
Rob Michaud
Staff Writer
Other articles...

Video interview: Splendy Games (The Bunker) interview

Xbox One PS4 PC Mac