Gabriel Knight: Sins of the Fathers review
The Good: Believable, interesting characters and a gripping storyline combined with great investigative game play based on true historical and religious backgrounds. One of the best adventure games ever written.
The Bad: A few of the puzzles might feel out of place in the well-realized setting. Tim Curry's "New Orleans" accent must be heard to be believed. Has difficulty in running on modern operating systems.
Our Verdict: The high point (and swan song) of Sierra's 2-D adventure era -- a wonderful introduction to the characters and world of Gabriel Knight.

 

An older man watches the fire, caught somewhere between his fear and the eyes of the dark woman who holds his gaze. A tear trickles down his cheek. She burns and grimaces and looks to the heavens - and as she does so she changes. Her features warp, twisting into an animalistic parody -- and then settle into those of a leopard.

 

He gasps as the snake coils about his neck, tightening, becoming the dark brown of a noose caught in the rain, the breeze. The rictus of his mouth glistens in the lightening.

Images -- a knife, a medallion, blood.

And Gabriel Knight awakens with a scream...

 

So begins Sins of the Fathers -- the first chapter in the Gabriel Knight series. Gabriel is a struggling author who has been trying to write his latest novel for weeks, to little avail. And now his strange nightmares are getting steadily worse.

The game follows his slow discovery of his family's history as he investigates what the police are calling the Voodoo Murders in his own backyard, New Orleans. Starting as a simple attempt to find a little atmosphere for his book, he uncovers a world he never knew existed, where the battle between good and evil takes on very real dimensions.

Gabriel works along side his assistant, Grace Nakimura, who runs the rare book shop he owns in the French Quarter. Grace's part in the first episode is minimal. Rather than being a playable character, she acts as a resource for Gabriel, performing research whenever she's asked. Together with Gabe's childhood friend, Detective Mosley, they learn of the secrets buried in Gabriel's family history and face the evils that have grown to fruition in the rich soil of New Orleans.

Sins is one of the many 2-D games Sierra produced, and the company's long and excellent history in the genre is evident. The hand drawn backgrounds and characters might seem a bit pixilated against the rendering technology of today, but they've lost none of their charm. Of particular interest is the use of a "comic book" style for several of the game's climactic scenes -- single, still panels appearing layered over one another.

The sound is very well done -- although implemented only in MIDI or SoundBlaster format. Leitmotifs appear in the music; there's a definite "Gabriel theme" that's established in the opening, and variations of it appear throughout the game, and indeed, the rest of the series.

The interface is a more detailed, complex version of the point-and-click functionality that appeared in King's Quests V and VI. Instead of a simple 'use' command, players must choose among 'push', 'operate', and 'take'. There are even two different operations for communicating with characters -- talk and interrogate. This finely-tuned interface allows users to be more precise in their actions.

The game was originally released in two formats -- disk and CD, each containing both the DOS Windows versions. The CD version had the added bonus of a full audio track, including voiceovers for all of the characters -- including the narrator. The voices are all done by Hollywood talent -- including Tim Curry, Mark Hamill, Michael Dorn, and Leah Remini. While some of them (Remini as Grace, particularly) work wonderfully, Curry's attempt at a Gabriel's New Orleans drawl is so overdone as to sometimes be grating, especially when put against the more authentic accent of the game's female narrator.

That being said, Sins of the Fathers is one of the best adventure games ever written. The mysterious premise is the perfect hook to pull the players into the supernatural world of Voodoo-haunted New Orleans. The player follows Gabriel step-by-step as he interrogates witnesses, finds clues, and slowly pieces the puzzle together.

The game is broken up into a set of ten days over which the story is told. Each day opens with a cinematic of the sun rising over the French Quarter along with a rhymed couplet -- a small part of a poem that is revealed in the course of the game. Each opening continues as Gabriel wakes up, grabs a cup of coffee and talks about his current situation with Grace. Between the couplets and the conversations, the player is given a clear set of goals to accomplish before the next day can continue, though the required actions to complete some days are not as logical as they could be (I'm thinking particularly of the ones revolving around what the poem refers to as "Bacchus' abode").

Conversation is a big part of the game play and is done through a rather elegant menu system. On either side, close-ups of Gabriel and his subject appear -- these look particularly good under VESA hi-res graphics option. The menu is a conceptual inventory -- a list of ideas and subjects that Gabriel has come across in his investigations. Clicking on one will cause Gabriel to ask a question pertinent to the situation at hand. Sometimes, the questions will lead to sub-menus of further lines of inquiry. Adding to the sense of atmosphere, all of the audio is lip-synched with the character close-ups.

Along with the interrogate tool, Gabriel also has the ability to simply chit-chat with people. This, combined with a fully-realized set of questions for each character about themselves, fleshes out the characters wonderfully. I spent much of opening of the game simply looking around the shop and asking Grace about herself and her background. The game includes a virtual tape recorder which Gabriel uses during his investigations. Using it, the player can replay any past conversation he's had -- which can be very useful in piecing together what's already been learned.

The puzzles are almost universally logical and well-implemented. One or two, while still straightforward, are less well-integrated, and are only noticeable because the rest of the game world is so well crafted. However, most of the puzzles are wonderful examples of their craft -- conundrums which force the player to utilize several sources of information and not a little intuition to complete. One particularly memorable one involves the decoding of a secret Voodoo language, and the creation of a new message towards a particular end.

The depth of the background material the game is based on is amazing as well. The history of New Orleans, the slave trade in the West Indies and the United States, the Haitian slave rebellion, Voodoun and African tribal religions all figure into the story of Sins of the Fathers.

Gabriel Knight 1 is an old game, and getting it to run on a modern operating system can be difficult. After trying several solutions (including running the game in DOSBox), I found two possible ways of playing the game in Windows XP. The Windows version will execute, if run in Compatibility Mode, but it's prone to crashes and the only way to save successfully is while the game is displaying the travel map of New Orleans (even after applying the latest patch). Running the game's DOS mode using VDMSound was much more successful, but unfortunately, the character voices would not work.

However, regardless of any technical difficulties you may face, and any slight annoyances in the implementation, I wholeheartedly recommend Gabriel Knight: Sins of the Fathers. It's a powerful, intriguing piece of work, and while not for children, it will most certainly appeal to anyone mature enough to handle its subject matter.



AD Gabriel Knight: Sins of the Fathers can be purchased at:
GOG   • Amazon  

Game Info

Gabriel Knight: Sins of the Fathers

Platform:
Mac, PC

Genre:
Mystery

Developer:
Sierra On-Line


Game Page »

Worldwide December 17 1993 Sierra On-Line

Where To Buy

Gabriel Knight: Sins of the Fathers

Get it DRM-free at

Available at

Affiliate Links

User Score

Average based on 51 ratings

Log in or Register to post ratings.

User Reviews

Posted by Kelop on Jun 5, 2014

Excels at suspense story and puzzles

It's a very good game that still upholds its quality. This opinion is free of any sentiment or nostalgic influence since now, over 20 years... Read the review »

Posted by MrChapeau on Mar 25, 2014

Dripping atmosphere

Make no mistake -- this game is wonderful. The characters are beautifully written and very believable. I like them and want to know them... Read the review »

Posted by fauryn on Oct 20, 2013

Great Adventure

The Good: A very good adventure, one of the best I have ever played. The story is about Gabriel Knight, a young writer and owner of a... Read the review »

Posted by TimovieMan on Sep 30, 2013

Adventure storytelling at its best.

It took me a good long while to get to what has long been hailed as one of the absolute best games the adventure genre has to offer. Now... Read the review »



Screenshots
Showing 3 of 30

About the Author
Dan Ravipinto
Staff Writer

Comments

varkatope varkatope
Dec 19, 2008

Fantastic game.

This website http://gkpatches.vogons.zetafleet.com/ includes patches that allow GK1 and GK2 to be played successfully on modern computers. I finished GK1 on a quadcore WinXP PC that was none too happy about playing the game properly before the patch. The music volume kept resetting after saving, but otherwise it worked great!

UK_John
Jan 31, 2010

As per first comment, there is an XP installer that puts all the data on your hard drive so you don’t need the CD in the drive, it gives a bigger FMV window and full size graphics for credit screens, etc. Under DOS these are all less than full screen for the credits and the FMV are couple centimetres square, with the XP Installer they are 3.5cm square!

Excellent review by the way! A BIG thumbs up!

Enlil
Aug 21, 2011

Great review!!!

This is the way a point n click game should be made!
Story/Atmosphere/Characters/Dialogues/Puzzles/Graphics(1992). All aspects deserve a 10 out of 10. I cannot think of any equivalents and I am into the genre since 1990.

Its really really sad many modern adventurers haven’t played it due to old graphics/playing issues on modern systems. For the true adventure fans I totally recommend reading the graphic novel of “Sins Of the Fathers”. It gives an even darker taste to the whole thing!

You can find it here: http://gkart.ucoz.com/load/5-1-0-8

ghettodoghammer
Oct 24, 2011

The only Gabriel Knight game that I liked, this one is a great adventure, much better than the two sequels that followed it.

tempestmichael
Feb 15, 2012

I loved this game as a kid,
but when I recently went to play it again
about half way through the game it occurred to me that every single antagonist in the game was a black guy and every protagonist was a white guy.

It would have thought it was just a coincidence if the game wasn’t already so ignorant towards voodoo culture.

Either way, I recommend this game if you’re desperate for a sierra style adventure,
but I have to give it the poorest of all rating for being ethnocentric and downright racist.

I really didn’t want to believe it was either,
so this opinion is completely objective
and yes portraying every black character in a story as being a “bad guy” is racist no matter how subtle it seems.

The pro’s section on this should really recognize that this is NOT based on any true historical and religious backgrounds accept for the the information about how voodoo came to New Orleans.
The cons section should also really point out the ethnocentric nature of how the characters are portrayed in this.
It’s the 21st century people.
We really should be recognizing these things by now.

subbi subbi
Feb 15, 2012

Right…..don’t be so downright sensitive with this pc lark…
So in GK1 there is one black main antagonist!
The following two sequels had white antagonists…..such horror….maybe I should play the racism card!!
And…oh…there arr a few nasty germans in the GK games aswel….should they be offended too?
I think there might even be a gay joke or two in it aswel…..awful! We should blame the designer for not just put Disney dialogue lines in it, so no one feels offended…..

Get real, it’s a story, not a documentary. Don’t like it? Play Torin’s Passage instead!

aimless
Feb 16, 2012

Yes, well, then maybe I should take offense at the two ‘white’ women who were portrayed as nitwits and believed in voodoo, being a woman myself.  As it happens, I don’t.  I know you find nitwits in all races, genders and colors.

Voodoo was brought over to this country from Africa.  What color did you expect the bad guys practicing it to be? subbi is right, get real.  A lot of history is going to offend you if you’re that sensitive.  And it is, as he/she said, a story, not a documentary.

subbi subbi
Feb 16, 2012

It would have been extremely funny if the Voodoo practitioners would be Chinese… ;-) Just because we don’t want contribute to the assumption that only black people are always cast as the bad guys.

Besides which, Tempestmichaels facts are not right:
Malia Gedde (who, for sure is more black than white) is ultimately considered a protagonist. He should have known this if he played the game until the end at all…

zane
Feb 16, 2012

geez.
first of all, officer frick is a (minor) antagonist and malia gedde is a (major) protagonist. So right there tempestmichael, your racial theory is total garbage.
Secondly, the review says “based on true historical and religious backgrounds.” Backgrounds does NOT mean specific events. It uses alot of terms and concepts from the voodoo relgion, such as the loa, hounfours, and ritual objects.

Bobbin Bobbin
Dec 13, 2013

This is the only GK game that I have not yet played. So I’m waiting on the revamped version. The other two games were brilliant. Thank you JJ, and thank you for pushing so hard for so long and revamping GK 1.



Post a comment

You need to be logged in to post comments. Not a member? Register now!