The Curse of Monkey Island review
The Good: Great graphics and sound, Monkey Island humour, good puzzles
The Bad: Rushed ending, lack of depth

The Curse of Monkey Island is the third instalment of the popular Monkey Island comedy series. The saga follows the adventures of the oddly named Guybrush Threepwood, the wannabe pirate who can hold his breath for ten minutes. The story again relies on the character triangle of Guybrush, Elaine (the governor of three Caribbean islands) and the evil undead pirate LeChuck, Guybrush's arch-enemy. The Curse of Monkey Island begins with Guybrush Threepwood lost at sea. Soon though, he is captured and that is where the game kicks off. After escaping from captivity, he finally proposes to Elaine, his long-term love… with a cursed diamond ring, which turns Elaine into a gold statue. The rest of the game focuses on breaking the curse, and escaping from the pirate LeChuck so that they can marry.

Act One is ridiculously easy, but thankfully things get better later on. The game has a familiar point n click interface and the Monkey Island method of conversation, where you have a multiple choice of witty answers. As in all LucasArts adventure games, you cannot die, and this makes for unlimited exploration without the fear of making the wrong decision. The puzzles are also traditional LucasArts fare – no ‘use-the-switch-and-pull-the-lever’ puzzles here. They range from the obvious and common sense to the ingenious lateral thinking. As with most games, there are a few illogical puzzles, but these are few and far between. To make things even better, you can choose to play an easier version of the game, with fewer and less difficult puzzles.

The graphics and animation are flawless – just what one would expect from a LucasArts game. In a departure from Monkey Island 2, where the graphics were as realistic as was possible at the time, The Curse’s graphics are cartoony, as in Sam and Max, or Day of the Tentacle. This refusal to take itself seriously adds immensely to the game’s charm. Backgrounds are very detailed, and although cartoon-style, are somehow realistic.

The characters, old and new, are all lovingly rendered in beautiful 2D. Monkey Island buffs will be thrilled at the return of Wally, the Voodoo Priestess, Stan and of course LeChuck himself. They serve to make a smooth transition from Monkey Island 2 to COMI. However, apart from Stan, these characters are criminally underdeveloped. Wally, for instance, is only seen in the beginning of the game, when he could have been so much more. The Voodoo Priestess is an important character in the first two Monkey Islands, but in The Curse, it is only really necessary to speak to her once. Again, her character could have done so much more.

There are also a plethora of new characters, such as Murray, the demonic talking skull, the barber pirates, Captain Rottingham (a new baddie!), Madame Xima and Dinghy Dog (reminiscent of Sam and Max).

The Monkey Island humour is here, along with the usual brilliant music, which is always relevant to what you are doing at the time. There is even different music for each character you talk to and the change is done so subtly that you hardly notice it. Your subconscious does though, and it adds greatly to the atmosphere of the game. The voices are done magnificently too.

As in all games, along with the plot there are several sub-plots and in-jokes. Although the game can be finished in no time at all, the real fun lies in replaying it and talking to all the characters, doing things you normally wouldn’t, often with hilarious results. For example, your relationship with Murray, although not essential to the game, gives endless amusement.

Among the highlights of the game are the dying scenes (hilarious), Stan freed from the coffin (although you’d need to have played Monkey 2 to understand that) and the ship battles. The battles are an element of strategy not usually found in adventure games – a welcome relief.

However good the game is, it must be said that it is far too short, and the ending is a little rushed. Two days of gameplay is simply not enough for a modern adventure game. The length also affects the depth of gameplay. You simply do not have enough time to develop relationships with other characters, and get truly immersed in the game’s world. After its predecessor, this comes as a big letdown. Also, the ending is an anticlimax, leaving the player thinking he could have done so much more, if only the game’s programmers had let him. Minor quibbles, to be sure, for this is a fantastic game, but it’s the little details that make the game sparkle…and quite frankly, this game does not.





Buy it at:

Game Info

The Curse of Monkey Island

Platform: PC

Genre: Comedy, Fantasy

Developer: LucasArts

More Game Info »

Releases
Territory Date Publisher
Worldwide November 1 1997 LucasArts
Affiliate Links

User Score

Average based on 45 ratings

Log in or Register to post ratings.

User Reviews

Posted by Antrax on Mar 10, 2013

The best game in the series

I've played every game in the series more than once. CoMI is, IMO, the best one.While Lechuck's Revenge (the most common choice for "best in... Read the review »

Posted by aftaklas on Jan 17, 2013

Nurdrage

Best game ever, a REAL classic.... Read the review »

Posted by Jaremaing on Jun 18, 2012

A hilarious and beautiful adventure.

I love Monkey Island. I played the original at a friend's house at a young age and thought it was really funny, but I didn't really play it... Read the review »

Posted by ponponpon on May 21, 2012

One of the best games ever!!!

I played that game as a kid (and not a very well English speaker), and that's why the long playing time. However, all the parameters of this... Read the review »



Screenshots
Showing 6 of 30

About the Author

Comments

Ursulla
Aug 31, 2009

Just finished this game….
The remake of the first game was all I needed to motivate me into playing the whole series….
It is not a secret that it is one of the most succesful and popular adventure games of all times….
At Gamespot 2,465 gamers voted for this game an average score of 9.3 !!! Not many adventures can beat that…
It is the last game by LucasArts that still can be played by ScummVM which works the game like a charm…
The puzzles of this game are challenging,creative and full of fun…
I do recommend it without any reservation….

My final verdict : Fun at its purest form…

ghettodoghammer
Sep 1, 2011

I thought this was one of my favorite games I ever played. The humor was hilarious, as this time around they were able to really make full use because of the voice, Although I did not like Dominic Armato as the voice of Guybrush, he sounded way too nerdy for a swashbuckler like the main character.

ghettodoghammer
Dec 3, 2011

Re-review in order! This review needs to be updated.

Sigma.40
Dec 12, 2011

Not as good as the first 2 but definitely one of the best adventure games. Ever.

Adventure Adventure
May 25, 2012

Aged well, a classic. Although I still prefer the 1st game as best in the series this is probably easier to get into if you somehow haven’t played a Monkey Island game yet.

ExBlade
Nov 30, 2012

This game deserves at least 6 stars Smile

Manuel Manuel
Dec 27, 2012

I completely disagree with this review,  it´s one of the best games ever made and it deserves much higher rating.

aftaklas
Jan 17, 2013

re-review +1, it isnt a coincidence that no comment aggrees with the review.

Jackal Jackal
Jan 17, 2013

That’s true. People who disagree with things do tend to be a lot more vocal, so it’s not a coincidence at all.

There’s no reason to re-review any game just so it validates a certain opinion, though. There’s user reviews for people to express their own.



Post a comment

You need to be logged in to post comments. Not a member? Register now!